Rancho Santa Fe, November 16, 2026
To: Thomas Walper, President
Members of the Rancho Santa Fe Art Jury
Rancho Santa Fe Association
P.O. Box A
Rancho Santa Fe, CA 92067
Copies to:
Board of Directors, Rancho Santa Fe Association
Dominique Albrecht, Chief Administrative Officer
Joel Levanetz, Building Commissioner
Re: Silvergate Project – Fundamental Inappropriateness for the Land; Unresolved Noncompliances and Design Issues That Must Be Addressed Before Any Final Vote
Dear President Walper and Members of the Art Jury:
Protect Rancho Santa Fe (PRSF) writes in advance of the Art Jury’s meeting this Tuesday regarding the proposed Silvergate project. The central point of this letter is that the project remains inappropriate for the subject land. The dual Class C and Class L designations, the established low-density pattern of development on this portion of the Ranch, the Protective Covenant’s closed list of Class C uses, Article I, Paragraph 1’s prohibition on institutions, the Residential Design Guidelines’ mandate to preserve the rural character through restraint in mass and scale, and the County of San Diego’s Semi-Rural SR-2 designation all confirm that this site is suited for low-density residential and equestrian uses, not a high-density, licensed institutional care campus.
This conclusion is reinforced by recent San Diego County Planning Development Services (PDS) and San Dieguito Community Planning Group materials. The County’s August 28, 2026 Final Major Pre-Application Scoping Letter (PDS2026-MPA-26-002) describes the proposal as a licensed care campus of 168 units on the site – specifically a licensed residential care facility for the elderly (RCFE). In short, the County’s own scoping document frames the project as a licensed, group-care campus rather than an ordinary low-density residential development – an institutional use that Article I, Paragraph 1 of the Protective Covenant and the closed list of Class C uses do not permit on this land.
On November 13, 2026, the San Dieguito Community Planning Group transmitted formal comments to SD County PDS affirming its support for the San Diego County General Plan, the San Dieguito Community Plan, and the established land-use designations, zoning framework, and density standards, and urging that they be honored and consistently applied as adopted by the Board of Supervisors.
In particular, the Planning Group stated:
• “Rancho Santa Fe is a historically established low-density estate residential community of the San Dieguito Planning Area.”
• “Most of the remaining vacant land is located on the fringes of various urbanizing areas and, as such, it is appropriate for low-intensity residential use compatible with Rancho Santa Fe land-use character.”
• “For community character reasons, any proposed new development on the subject parcels must preserve the existing Semi-Rural SR-2 General Plan designation and Rural Residential (RR) zoning, maintaining the established San Dieguito estate residential character that dates back over a hundred years.”
These statements directly underscore that the site is suited for low-density residential and equestrian uses consistent with the Protective Covenant and the County’s Semi-Rural SR-2 designation – not a high-density, multi-building institutional care campus. A County permit, if ever issued, does not amend the Protective Covenant or relieve the Association and Art Jury of their independent duties to apply the governing documents as written. The project’s density of approximately 7.3 units per acre – where a minimum of 1 unit to 2.86 acres are the specified norm – on the reduced ~23-acre site, multi-building institutional form, employee intensity, and memory-care component remain incompatible with the land. If built in its current form, the project would house approximately 5% of the total population of the Covenant on less than 0.5% of our land.
In addition to this fundamental mismatch, several specific, unresolved problems remain that the Art Jury has not fully addressed. These issues must be resolved – through redesign into compliance or through a proper variance process with the findings required by the Regulatory Code – before the Art Jury takes any final vote to approve or advance the project.
1. Overall Scale, Bulk, and Mass, Including the Memory Care Second Floor
The project remains too large for the site. At the October 28, 2025 meeting, after reviewing story poles and hearing extensive public comment, the Art Jury identified excessive bulk and mass – particularly second-story elements – and expressed a clear preference for a one-story Memory Care building to reduce bulk at the project perimeter. The applicant subsequently implemented reductions, including elimination of the Memory Care building’s second story. At the March 10, 2026 meeting, however, the Art Jury advanced the application to Plan Review while stating that, in light of other reductions, it was “willing to reconsider the inclusion of a second-story element on the Memory Care building.” This suggestion was not the subject of additional public discussion as was promised. Advancing the project effectively treated the second-story element as acceptable without the process that the Art Jury’s own prior directives and its charge under Protective Covenant Paragraphs 46, 47, 52, and 153-154 require. The Art Jury’s mission is to ensure designs are reasonably appropriate to their site and harmonious with their surroundings and to preserve the rural character of the Ranch. Reversing a documented reduction directive without further public process is inconsistent with that charge and with the expectation of consistent application of standards.
The data confirm that the project is now greater in intensity than it was when the Art Jury last directed reductions. At the October 28, 2025 meeting, the project encompassed approximately 28.7 acres (including two non-Covenant parcels), with site coverage of 293,049 square feet (23.5 percent) and roughly 160–162 units. By the November 2026 stage, the site has been reduced to 999,975 square feet (~23.0 acres); site coverage stands at 262,633 square feet (26.3 percent) – a higher coverage percentage on a smaller site – and total units are now 168 – the same order of magnitude and a higher unit count than the Art Jury reviewed in October 2025 when it required downsizing and removal of the Memory Care second floor.
In short, after the Art Jury sent the project back to reduce bulk and mass, the applicant removed land rather than intensity. The result is a denser project with greater lot coverage percentage and essentially the same number of units the Art Jury found excessive in October 2025. Further, the subsequent enlargement of 40 apartment units to meet the 1,750-square-foot minimum came with no reduction in unit count. The project is currently larger in density and coverage intensity than the version the Art Jury directed be reduced last October.
2. Remaining Undersized Apartment Units Lacking Kitchens
Regulatory Code §43.0301 requires that the enclosed living space in each Unit of a Multifamily Building shall not be less than 1,750 square feet. A “Unit” is defined as “a complete, independent living facility for one or more persons, including permanent provisions for living, sleeping, eating, cooking, and sanitation and having a kitchen.” As detailed in PRSF’s July 28, 2026 letter to the Board of Directors (copied to the Art Jury) and confirmed by consultant analysis, earlier plans showed 52 apartment units at only 1,440 square feet (17.7 percent below the minimum). The Association acknowledged that a variance is required for units of this size. It is PRSF’s understanding that the applicant increased the size of 40 of those units to meet the minimum. For the remaining 12 units, however, the applicant has removed the kitchens and reduced the unit size. This does not resolve the noncompliance. These still undersized units – now lacking kitchens – fail the Code’s own definition of a “Unit” and remain subject to the 1,750-square-foot minimum.
These units are also untenantable under California Civil Code § 1941.1. For leases entered into, amended, or extended on or after January 1, 2026, a dwelling is untenantable if it substantially lacks a stove maintained in good working order capable of safely generating heat for cooking purposes and a refrigerator maintained in good working order capable of safely storing food. The limited exceptions in subdivision (b) (permanent supportive housing, certain single-room occupancy units, residential hotel units, and units within a housing facility offering shared or communal kitchen spaces) do not apply to these conventional independent-living apartment units from which private cooking facilities have been deliberately removed. As set forth in PRSF’s November 10, 2026 letter to the Board of Directors (copied to the Art
Jury) and the accompanying analysis, the 12 units remain noncompliant with both the Regulatory Code and state habitability law. The Art Jury previously recognized, on October 8, 2024, that a variance must be sought for apartment units less than 1,750 square feet or the floorplans redesigned. No proper variance application under §1.24 has been processed. The four required findings – including that the variance will not nullify the intent and purpose of the Code (to regulate appearance and intensity of use and preserve community character) and will not be injurious to the neighborhood or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare – must be made on evidence if a variance is pursued. These units must be brought into compliance or a variance duly obtained with findings before further substantive advancement.
3. Grading and Berms in Association Setbacks
The applicant proposes substantial grading in the Rancho Santa Fe Association setbacks, with the stated rationale that berms will be constructed in lieu of retaining walls. The land on which these berms are proposed has little to no slope; retaining walls were not required in the first place. Per the County’s August 28, 2026 Final MPA Scoping Letter, the overall earthwork is anticipated to involve approximately 45,800 cubic yards of cut, 83,000 cubic yards of fill, and 37,200 cubic yards of imported fill. Prior Art Jury comments (including February 4, 2025) already noted ongoing concerns about the amount of grading and berms, particularly in the southwest corner. Chapter 41 of the Regulatory Code is a Slope Protection Regulation whose purpose is “to preserve natural landforms, including slopes, ridgelines, and valleys, through the establishment of development and Grading standards and requirements to maintain the rural character and landform features of the community.” Section 41.16 provides that “Grading and Site Retaining Walls shall be avoided in the Rancho Santa Fe Association setbacks” except for limited circumstances: necessary grading for entry driveways and fire access (with walls only if integral to the entry experience and used to limit grading), trails and bioswales, or an exception where the Art Jury finds that Landform Grading in the setbacks allows a substantial reduction in grading, site retaining walls, and tree removals on the entire property. Berms on essentially flat land in the setbacks do not fall within these exceptions. These features conflict with the requirement to integrate improvements with the natural landform, to use landform or contour grading, and to avoid manufactured elements that undermine the rural character. The proposed setback grading should be redesigned to comply with Chapter 41 or, if an exception is sought, supported by the required findings before further advancement.
All of the foregoing items – fundamental appropriateness for the land, the second-story Memory Care issue, the 12 undersized units, and the setback grading and berms -should be fully addressed and resolved before the Art Jury takes a final vote on approving the project. Continuing to process noncompliant plans, or treating prior reductions as optional, undermines the Art Jury’s responsibility under the Protective Covenant and the Regulatory Code to ensure a uniform and reasonably high standard of artistic result, to preserve the rural character of the Ranch, and to protect neighboring properties and the established low-density pattern of development.
When the Art Jury and Association Staff do not consistently apply the Protective Covenant and the Regulatory Code as written, they undermine their credibility with the membership they are charged to serve.
PRSF respectfully requests that the Art Jury withhold any recommendation of final approval until these matters are corrected or properly varied with findings.
Respectfully submitted on behalf of the Board of Directors of Protect Rancho Santa Fe,
Russ Penniman
Board President
Protect Rancho Santa Fe
Enclosures:
1. San Dieguito Community Planning Group email of November 13, 2026, transmitting comments on the August 28, 2026 Final MPA Scoping Letter (PDS2026-MPA-26-002)
2. Protect Rancho Santa Fe letter to the Board of Directors dated July 28, 2026, regarding undersized apartment units and Regulatory Code §43.0301

