You are currently viewing Letter to the RSFA Board and Art Jury, November 10, 2026

Letter to the RSFA Board and Art Jury, November 10, 2026

Rancho Santa Fe, November 10, 2026

Board of Directors

Dominique Albrecht, Chief Administrative Officer

Art Jury

Joel Levanetz, Building Commissioner

Rancho Santa Fe Association
P.O. Box A
Rancho Santa Fe, CA 92067

***By email***
Re: Silvergate Project – Regulatory Code §43.0301 Noncompliance; California Civil Code §1941.1 Habitability Requirements; Requirement That the Remaining 12 Undersized Units Be Brought into Compliance

Dear President LeBeau, Members of the Board, and Members of the Art Jury:

Protect Rancho Santa Fe writes to update its position regarding the Silvergate project’s noncompliance with Regulatory Code §43.0301 and to address the implications of California dwelling habitability law. Enclosed for your reference are (1) the October 7, 2026 memorandum from Ekard Smith & Associates analyzing the variance findings under §1.24, and (2) a November 10, 2026 memorandum analyzing California Civil Code § 1941.1 as applied to the remaining units.

As previously detailed in our July 28, 2026 letter to the Art Jury, our August 19, 2026 letter to the Board, and as confirmed in the enclosed Ekard Smith memorandum, the plans then under review showed that 52 apartment units contained only 1,440 square feet of enclosed living space – 310 square feet, or 17.7 percent, below the mandatory minimum of 1,750 square feet.

It is PRSF’s understanding that Silvergate subsequently increased the size of 40 of those apartment units to meet the 1,750-square-foot minimum. For the remaining 12 units, however, Silvergate has removed the kitchens and reduced the unit size.

This approach does not resolve the noncompliance. Regulatory Code §43.0301 states in full:

“The enclosed living space in each Unit of a Multifamily Building shall not be less than 1,750 square feet. Specifically excluded from the calculation of enclosed living space shall be garages, porches, patios and breezeways. For the purposes of this paragraph, a ‘Unit’ means a complete, independent living facility for one or more persons, including permanent provisions for living, sleeping, eating, cooking and sanitation and having a kitchen.”

Because the Code applies the 1,750-square-foot minimum to “each Unit of a Multifamily Building”, and because each unit is defined as a complete, independent living facility that must include permanent provisions for cooking and a kitchen, removing the kitchens does not exempt the 12 units from the size requirement. Units lacking kitchens fail the Code’s own definition of a “Unit.”

Under California law, such units would also be untenantable.

California Civil Code § 1941.1(a) provides that a dwelling shall be deemed untenantable if it substantially lacks any of the affirmative standard characteristics enumerated therein. For leases entered into, amended, or extended on or after January 1, 2026, those characteristics expressly include a stove maintained in good working order and capable of safely generating heat for cooking purposes (paragraph (10)) and a refrigerator maintained in good working order and capable of safely storing food (paragraph (11)).

Subdivision (b) carves out limited exceptions to the stove and refrigerator requirements only. Those exceptions apply solely to permanent supportive housing (as defined in Government Code § 8698.4(c)(2)), certain single-room occupancy units, residential hotel units (Health & Safety Code § 50519(b)(1)), and dwelling units within a housing facility that offers shared or communal kitchen spaces to its residents.

The 12 Silvergate units do not fall under these excepted provisions.

As analyzed in the enclosed November 10, 2026 memorandum, Silvergate is a proposed senior living community comprising independent-living apartments, cottages, and a separate memory-care component. The 12 units originated as apartment units within the multifamily buildings subject to §43.0301. They are not permanent supportive housing, single-room occupancy units, or residential hotel units. The statute’s exception for units in a “housing facility that offers shared or communal kitchen spaces” (including assisted living) does not extend to conventional independent-living apartment units from which private cooking facilities have been deliberately removed in an effort to reduce square footage. Removing private kitchens from otherwise independent residential units does not transform them into the specialized housing types enumerated in § 1941.1(b).

Accordingly, under both the Association’s Regulatory Code and California Civil Code § 1941.1, the 12 units remain noncompliant. They cannot lawfully be offered as tenantable dwellings without permanent provisions for cooking (including a stove), and they cannot evade the 1,750-square-foot minimum by the expedient of removing the very kitchen that the Code requires for a “Unit.”

The Art Jury recognized the mandatory nature of the size requirement on October 8, 2024, when it directed: “A variance must be sought for apartment units less than 1,750 sq. ft. in size per Regulatory Code Section 43.0301. Alternatively, re-design the Apartment Unit floorplans to be a minimum of 1,750 sq. ft.” Subsequent minutes that softened this to “a variance may be required” were inaccurate and inconsistent with both the Code and the Art Jury’s own earlier action.

As the enclosed Ekard Smith memorandum emphasizes, the Association’s recent practice – illustrated by the Gateway project – has been to address variance requirements as soon as they are identified. Continuing project review while units remain noncompliant is neither fair to the applicant nor consistent with the Governing Documents. If a variance is ultimately denied, the applicant will need to redesign; delaying that determination is costly for the applicant and unnecessarily time-consuming for the Art Jury, the Board, and Covenant members.

Under §1.24, a variance “shall only be approved if (1) such variance will not have the effect of nullifying the intent and purpose of the Code and (2) the Board of Directors makes all of the following findings based upon the evidence presented to it in each specific case.” Among the required findings are:

§1.2401.1: “The granting of the variance… will not be injurious to the neighborhood or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare”;
§1.2401.02: “The conditions upon which the request for a variance is based are unique to the property for which the variance is sought and are not applicable generally to other property”; and
§1.2401.03: “Because of the particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the specific property involved, a particular hardship to the owner would result, as distinguished from a mere inconvenience, if the strict letter of the Code is carried out.”

Section 1.24 further requires a finding of “extraordinary hardships or practical difficulties” resulting from strict compliance.

Allowance of variances for these 12 units would be injurious to the neighborhood and out of character with the land. Chapter 43 states that its purpose is “to regulate appearance and intensity of use and to preserve community character.” Units substantially smaller than the Code minimum – and units deliberately stripped of kitchens to achieve that reduction – increase intensity of use in direct conflict with that purpose. Section 1.10 of the Code reinforces the same goals: to “Preserve, continue and maintain community character,” “Restrict the use, height and bulk of buildings,” and “Protect the rural character and ambiance of the community.” Approving undersized units that lack required cooking facilities would systematically undercut these bright- line intensity controls, conflict with state habitability standards, and set a precedent inconsistent with the Governing Documents.

Any claim of financial hardship is not the hardship contemplated by the Code.

As the Ekard Smith memorandum notes, §1.24 addresses site-based conditions “particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions” – that create extraordinary hardship distinguished from mere inconvenience. The subject parcels are large and flat. The undersized units, and the removal of kitchens from the remaining 12, result from the applicant’s preferred design and business objectives, not from any unique physical constraint of the property. A self-imposed difficulty in achieving a desired unit count or financial return does not satisfy §1.2401.03 or the introductory standard of extraordinary hardship or practical difficulty. Variances under §1.24 are unavailable for uses and are unavailable for hardships the applicant itself has created. Section 1.2402 confirms that variances are not applicable for “uses.”

We therefore respectfully request that the Board and Art Jury take no further action on the Silvergate project until the plans are revised so that every apartment unit – including the remaining 12 – contains not less than 1,750 square feet of enclosed living space calculated in accordance with §43.0301 and includes permanent provisions for cooking (a kitchen with a stove) so as to constitute a “Unit” under the Code and a tenantable dwelling under California Civil Code § 1941.1. Alternatively, if the applicant seeks to pursue variances, individual variance applications for each of the 12 units must be formally submitted, noticed, and decided by the Board under §1.24, with all required findings made on the basis of evidence, and only after the units are designed to satisfy applicable state habitability requirements.

Respectfully submitted on behalf of the Board of Directors of Protect Rancho Santa Fe,

Russ Penniman
President of the Board
Protect Rancho Santa Fe

Enclosures:
1. October 7, 2026 memorandum from Ekard Smith & Associates
2. November 10, 2026 memorandum analyzing California Civil Code § 1941.1 as applied to the remaining 12 Silvergate units

cc: Peter Smith, Ekard Smith & Associates